So you might have been drinking soda and spilled some on your F150’s mat by mistake. You get annoyed with an oversized mat that gets in the way of pushing the pedal. Still, dirt stains from extreme weather or the need for a simple change are not that big of a deal but could lead to a pivotal change.
The point is that you might need a quick and easy solution. I got you covered. My analysis consists of the great debate and comparison between the Husky Liners and WeatherTech, two top manufacturers in the floor mats market.
I’d advise you to stick to the article until the end so you understand the answer to the WeatherTech vs. Husky debate and, as a result, make the best buying choice. The fact that WeatherTech is more widely known for floor mat production while Husky is more for efficacy through affordable costs isn’t enough. This is why the analysis is going more in-depth, and there’s a detailed comparison for a wide range of factors.
WeatherTech vs. Husky: Things in Common
Interestingly, even though the two producers are great competitors, they are ahead of most automotive floor mat manufacturers in using separate tools and technologies. Some of these innovative approaches are similar in both of the products.
Automotive Floor Mats Top Manufacturers
The competitive spirit between the two and their constant innovation has made them the top manufacturers and sellers in the floor mats market. This might also stem from the fact that both come from built-in technologies that fit the edges. They make sure to shield the floor, combatting muck and fluids.
Simple Installation
Another critical similarity, which derives from the previous point, is a simple installation in both of the two brands’ products. The quick adjustment to your own needs and your own car’s angles is relevant when looking into the best, and fortunately, both brands possess that characteristic.
Easy to choose
You don’t need to cut or drill them. You also don’t need to search for a product with a broader range of colors. They both come out in gray, black, and tan colors.
100% USA Products
Finally, the protection of floor mats from spills, weather, floods, and other conditions is guaranteed from understanding and production in the USA. No product of the two comes from outside of the United States.
WeatherTech All-Weather Floor Mats
(Ford F-150 / F-150 Raptor)
Husky Liners WeatherBeater Floor Liners
(2015-2022 Ford F-150)
WeatherTech vs. Husky: Key Differences
Nonetheless, let’s get to the main event of tonight, shall we? What are the key differences? What is the best product for your needs? Once and for all, what’s the answer to the WeatherTech vs. Husky debate? To answer all of the questions and indicate the different components’ factors, I categorize the analysis into these main aspects: material, construction, design, price, and warranty.
| Parameters | WeatherTech | Husky |
|---|---|---|
| Material | High-Density Tri-Extruded (HDTE) and Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPE) | Thermoplastic Rubber and elastomers |
| Weight | Heavier | Lighter |
| Construction | Robust and powerful core, rigid gripping surface | Robust, gripping surface with higher edges |
| Design | Advanced surface channels, more flexible | Raised edges, diamond-plate patterns & grooves |
| Price | More expensive | Cheaper |
| Warranty | Limited | Lifetime |
In a nutshell, the WeatherTech mats are more close to the perfect rigid thermoplastic product, while the Husky output is part of a more tough rubberized thermoplastic composition. They will both do a great job protecting your truck, but the martial used is the fundamental aspect of the entire debate.
Material
The WeatherTech floor liners are using High-Density Tri-Extruded (HDTE) material. It’s super durable and provides all-weather protection and advanced surface channels to handle extreme weather conditions. As for floor mats products, WeatherTech uses the recyclable Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPE), an advanced rubber-like material that contains no latex, PVCs, cadmium, or lead.
The material that is used for the Husky Floor Liners is, as stated before, Thermoplastic Rubber and elastomers. They do a great job perfectly balancing the floor mat’s strength and softness. In this manner, they provide a better, more rubberized technology that causes better grip.
Who wins: WeatherTech
Construction
As mentioned above, the WeatherTech products have been constructed through HDTE technology, giving a more robust and powerful core. This is capitalized by the rigid gripping surface, which minimizes the movement of the car’s carpet once it’s planted on the ground. The pliable thermoplastic material is developed on the trim-to-fit mentality.
The construction of the Husky floor mat is a little bit different, and that’s because there’s a more comprehensive array of options. In addition to the technology of the thermoplastic Rubber, the liners have also been constructed through a Patented Formfit Technology and Laser measurement. As stated in the similarities section, the robust grip stays the same. What changes in the construction are the higher edges.
Who wins: Husky
Design
The last part of the previous factor leads to the next point. The Husky floor mats and liners are customized models which use raised edges. In addition to that, however, they also have diamond-plate patterns and grooves to channel fluids and ensure that the Coca-Cola you ordered with your BigMac stays away from your clothing and carpet.
The design isn’t entirely different in the Husky vs. Weathertech floor mats, but the former is more flexible. It is available in a variety of sizes and designs and fits almost any vehicle.
Who wins: WeatherTech
Price
As the article mentions before, the price factor plays a huge and significant role. Although the custom-fit of the WeatherTech car mats are surprisingly thermoplastic, flexible, and strong, they are also expensive.
In contrast, Husky liners also possess good grip, available in Rubber and thermoplastic, but for a lower and cost-efficient price.
Who wins: Husky
Warranty
The devil is in the details, and components such as the warranty might give one product a slight advantage over its competitor. Husky products provide a lifetime warranty, while the WeatherTech mats come with a limited, three-year contract.
Who wins: Husky
Read more: The Best Exhaust Tip For Deep Sound 2022 [Review & Buying Guide]
WeatherTech FloorLiner HP
(Ford F-150)
Husky Liners X-act Contour Floor Liners
( 2015-2022 Ford F-150)
WeatherTech vs. Husky: Detailed Reviews
The stigma around marketing and branding of today’s world might lead to conclusions such as products being different or being unrealistically presented. Therefore, I always want to take the word of previous customers and buyers of the specific products I am analyzing.
The stance that’s being kept is neutral, the objectivity is obvious, and the utmost purpose is to help you gain insight into the facts before making a decision.
WeatherTech Reviews
In most consumers’ minds, WeatherTech must be known for floor mats. The brand’s exclusivity makes it unique and gives another reason to trust the manufacturer, even if you’re a first-time buyer.
What I like
First of all, the biggest strength of WeatherTech’s products is the excellent natural protection against any weather. This is thanks to the material as well as the well-built construction.
From the pictures of the advertisement, customers have stated that the floor mat of the company seemed like a sticky surface. In reality, the product is everything but moist, difficult to clean, and ‘smelly.’ Customers have talked about the odorless finish that WeatherTech possesses. In my opinion, though it’s not as odorless as advertised, it emits less odor compared to Husky.
Another thing that people don’t understand just from looking at the picture is that the product isn’t flexible. It seems like it, but most buyers have described it as a stiff and robust surface with stable plastic construction. This is tough material for this particular product, and the mat won’t possibly wear out for an entire lifetime.
WeatherTech FloorLiner HP
1st Row (Driver & Passenger) for Ford F-150
What I don’t like
Nonetheless, some reviews indicate some of the cons of the products from WeatherTech. In reality, the floor mat isn’t adjustable and custom for every car position. The WeatherTech product needs cutting and adjusting for the rear seats.
And don’t get me wrong; the stiff production, the robust structure, and the lasers of the mat make it easy to stay attached to the floorboard of every car. Nonetheless, I wish you good luck in getting the mat to sit flush, should your edges curl for some reason. This disadvantage might seem a big deal for people with OCD and perfectionists.
Finally, even though it’s a product of exceptional quality, it is expensive (also considering the details above that might stop you from finding it perfect).
2nd Row for F-150
Let’s sum it up: WeatherTech Pros and Cons
Pros
- Classy look·
- Durable
- Emit less odor
- All-weather protection
- Wide compatibility·
- Simple installation
Cons
- More expensive
- Cutting and adjustments needed for rear seats
Read more: 5 Best Oils for 3.5 EcoBoost [Review & Buying Guide]
WeatherTech TechCare FloorLiner and FloorMat Cleaner/Protector Kit
Husky Liners Reviews
In most customers’ minds, the Husky Liner is a product that comes from a company transforming to the model of the WeatherTech. That’s not necessarily expressed as copying the agenda but thriving towards the mat production for car and truck protection.
What I like
Comparing the characteristics to the WeatherTech production, you’ll find it has the same form of designing and laser-measurement, making it the same stiff and hard product. Nonetheless, some different factors make people move towards this product more, and I will categorize them accordingly.
The price has led many to choose the Husky Liners above its competitor because most general characteristics are the same. The additional factor is the warranty. If you know that you are set for life regarding the product you are purchasing, your mindset is different. This is even more capitalized when taking the price into account.
Husky Liners WeatherBeater Floor Liners
2015-2022 Ford F-150 SuperCrew with carpeting
What I don’t like
Nonetheless, as mentioned before, many people might think this way, but also, a lot of people might be ready to change the product once they review it. Some of them care about having the best product, and even though both look very similar to one another, the quality of the Husky Liners isn’t at the same level as WeatherTech.
Why? Because it’s not a mat with the elastomeric material that WeatherTech possesses. It doesn’t have the same ability to enchant stain resistance. It’s not that durable, and at the end of the day, buyers state that the Husky Liners tend not to fit into the most modern car and truck models. They support older automobile vehicles, like a 2000 F-150, as it seems.
Husky Liners X-act Contour Floor Liners
2015-2022 Ford F-150 SuperCrew
Let’s sum it up: Husky Liners Pros and Cons
Pros
- Attractive look
- Soft and elastic
- Cheaper
- Simple installation
- Lifetime warranty
Cons
- Doesn’t fit most modern car/truck models
- Less durable
Read more: 8 Best Tonneau Covers For F-150 2022 [Review & Buying Guide]
Final Thoughts: Is Husky Liners or WeatherTech Better?
The final section must continue from the previous one and remind you that this isn’t an attempt to take a stance or provide an opinion. It’s an attempt to make a well-rounded analysis of the comparison and help you answer the debate.
Therefore, I am not saying that WeatherTech is better than Husky Liners or vice-versa. I am saying that one product is better for some factors and the other product is superior to some other factors.
If you are a consumer whose entire mindset is based on receiving the utmost quality, you will be looking to WeatherTech for your needs’ accommodation.
That’s why it would be reasonable to define quality as the way of construction, the design, and the material used. Keeping that in mind, the product from WeatherTech has fewer chances of being something you didn’t expect. The details might have less impact on its use than what would be the case for Husky Liners.
On the other hand, if you are a consumer who always wants to find the best deal with a sustainable solution, you will have to go with the Husky Liners. This brand’s products help customers find a balance. That’s the balance between having a cost-efficient product while at the same time not providing inadequate value compared to its big competitor.
All in all, I hope my well-rounded analysis can assist you in making the most affordable, quick, and effective purchase possible.